Wednesday, February 10, 2021

How the Edge Misleads

 The leading edge is a common term in business, so common that it is often jokingly termed the bleeding edge. Many distributions in life follow a bell curve, concentrated in the middle, and where the left hand group early adopters or the first over the parapet, can be termed the leading edge. This could represent the first customers of a new product, or the first firms trying to monetise a new technology, or the first people able to overcome some barrier.

 

It is just as well that most distributions naturally follow a normal or bell pattern. An illustrative example is the demand for Covid vaccines. The supply follows a standard bell curve, because some companies are quicker than others in developing a vaccine and some authorities are quicker in making one available. But the demand is not a bell curve at all; instead most people want a jab as soon as possible. The result is a market failure and a mismatch of supply and demand. Luckily, in most situations both supply and demand have features leading to a bell distribution, so both sides have a chance of matching each other, and also of adapting from early adopters.

 

It is these early adopters that led me to a concept I introduced last week and called the misleading edge. The issue is that early adopters are in no way typical, but special – that is how they become early adopters. And while early adopters offer the opportunity for adaptation and learning, the fact that they are special creates various risks from the wrong lessons being learned.

 

I believe an illustrative example arises in uses of new technologies. Some bright spark works out that a device like a wristwatch can be produced that offers medical data such as heart rate. The first producer is a computer nerd, so puts little effort into an easy user experience, instead opting for complexity. The first customers, the early adopters, are also nerdy, young fitness fanatics.

 

The producer looks at these first results and draws conclusions. Yes, there is a market for this product. Fitness fanatics are interested in all sorts of data, and are quite prepared to navigate small screens to secure a plethora of information. As a result, the producer doubles down on this customer segment. They succeed in creating a profitable niche.

 

What is the problem? It is possible that the producer has spurned a far larger opportunity, and a far more beneficial one for society. Older, less fit people could derive medical information from such a device that might save their life or at least improve its quality. But these people don’t see the marketing. If they see the marketing, they find it confusing. If by luck their child spots the marketing, works out its value for mum, and gives it as a gift, the parent still does not use it because the screen is too small to read and the user manual is full of technical claptrap. The producer does not see the potential, or gives up too soon, and fails to make the adaptations to unlock the true potential of the innovation. The early adopters have given misleading signals that have placed the technology or a sub-optimal trajectory.

 

I believe this is one reason why many new technologies remain niche for longer than they should. I also believe that a corporate culture that refuses to fall into the misleading edge trap is one reason behind the success of Apple.

 

The misleading edge applies just as much in situations that have nothing to do with products. An important example concerns diversity and inclusion, and the speed with which a minority enters an arena they had previously been excluded from.

 

Last week I argued that the women that first became successful in many fields often had special characteristics. That is just what one would expect; the problem is that this misleading edge of early adapters caused the wrong lessons to be drawn, damaging the wider diversity project.

 

I identified three archetypes of early successes. The first group are phenomena, women of such exceptional talents that they could knock down any barrier. Then there are impersonators, women who happen to have a set of skills more common in men, and thereafter equipped to succeed in a game still biased by rules set by men. The third group are kittens, women picked by men for reasons that suit men, including pliability or flattery or lack of threat.

 

The phenomena are fantastic examples but flawed role models, because few can emulate their talents. The myth of the American dream is perpetuated because a few phenomena demonstrate what is possible: it is just highly unlikely. By the same token, men can sustain a set of biased rules by pointing out that it is plainly possible to succeed; they can also delude themselves that the rules are not biased. Finally, the phenomena can make the men feel inadequate, and cause them to delay any relaxation of those rules.

 

The impersonators are also poor role models, because they might lead others to try to emulate their methods in order to succeed, directly contrary to the goal of broadening the diversity of skills and behaviours. Through no fault of their own, impersonators can prolong an exclusive culture. This cohort is also rather open to derision and unconscious bullying.

 

The kittens have an even more insidious success. They are often over-promoted and struggle, at the expense of their own mental health. They allow the exclusive group to maintain domination, while convincing themselves and others that the culture has changed, and also perpetuate the myth that women are somehow unsuitable or inferior.

 

The correct response to those at a leading edge is to welcome them and support them but avoid taking unhelpful lessons from them. This may take patience, and may also involve challenging advice offered by those from the leading edge and their advocates. Even if a quota is reached quickly, that does not imply success or a reason to slow down diversity efforts. Success is only assured once the profiles of successful women are themselves as diverse as those of their male colleagues.

 

The pitfalls of the misleading edge apply equally to other aspects of human diversity. The early ethnically different leaders often have a colonial type background, making them impersonators. Early LBGT leaders could be either impersonators or kittens, so much so that for a time the typical profile of a gay man among straight society was far from representative. We can celebrate these successes, but must double down until a wider sample break through the barriers. Many of these journeys remain far from complete.

 

Many companies in the developed world have reached a stage where they believe they have achieved true diversity. They would do well to look beyond the quotas and to look beyond the examples offered by the misleading edge. Until they do, they are more likely to emulate Fitbit (market capitalisation $1.7Bn) than Apple ($2.3 Trn).      

Tuesday, February 2, 2021

The Misleading Edge

 Over Christmas we watched the latest series of The Crown, and enjoyed it very much. The portrayals of Charles and Diana were believable. Everybody likes to vilify one of them and sanctify the other, but I have believed that they were both victims of nearly impossible circumstances. In particular, Charles was let down by his male role models. To its credit, the series pulled few punches, though I would have appreciated or more edgy portrayal of Prince Andrew. Perhaps we can look forward to that in the last two series.

 

The timeline for the series coincided with the decade that Margaret Thatcher dominated British politics. She is another character who divides, in that most people either adore her or hate her. I lean towards the latter, but I do accept that some of her reforms were timely. We left-wingers tend to gloss over the winter of discontent and the hegemony of Jones, Scanlon and Scargill. A correction was needed, just not a correction of the scale and heartlessness that thatcher provided.

 

One of the funniest moments in the series came when the Queen sought a clubby companionship with Thatcher by pointing out that they were both women of a similar age, and how remarkable it was to have such power in the hands of women. The Queen then asked why Thatcher had not appointed any other women to her cabinet. Thatcher replied with a misogynist remark that in her judgment (or experience, or opinion), women were not up to the job. Olivia Coleman’s face spoke volumes. I have no idea whether the conversation actually took place, but it does seem consistent with Thatcher’s personality.

 

Thatcher did not really consider herself a woman, at least not in the aspect of competence for senior executive positions. She was certainly a phenomenon. As a woman, we could also call her an impersonator. Her route to success was to behave like a man, indeed an extreme version of masculinity.

 

While we were watching the series, I got into a family conversation about our worst bosses. In Shell I had over twenty bosses: most of them were not very good, and the later ones tended to be worse than the early ones. I believe the role of boss is under-trained, misunderstood and also under-resourced, in that most bosses are expected to do so much else that they usually can’t find the time to do their boss job properly.

 

It was easy to decide my worst boss, an unfortunate gentleman recruited from outside into Shell who was comically out of his depth. At least, it was comical when we could overlook the damage his appointment did to the business, his team and to himself. He certainly was a major contribution to my breakdown in 2000.

 

What struck me was the winners of the silver and bronze medals in the terrible boss competition. I awarded those accolades to my only two female bosses.

 

The first was a bit of a Thatcher character, ruthless, ambitious and uncompromising. Those attributes are not always disastrous, but in the case of this woman they were allied with selfishness and some paranoia, leading her to betray her own team and others with some regularity.

 

The second was completely different. She was a delightful, charming woman, not lacking in insight, but promoted out of her depth and revealed as unable to make decisions or to lead. As a subordinate, I was faced was a blockage above me whenever I wanted to get anything done.

 

This last boss feels like a classic example of a third archetype I might call a kitten. Her femininity had drawn favourable attention of men throughout her career, and they were seduced into promoting her. She was the sort of woman that men were delighted to have as a peer, a pleasure to be round a no real competition to their own ambition.

 

In the case of female leaders, I suspect these three archetypes used to be typical of the few who first made it into the higher ranks. There were a few phenomena, immensely talented women who could not be stopped, and who were great motivators to other women but not really good examples of role models, since most simply lacked their talent. There were rather more impersonators, able to succeed by being like men, suppressing their femininity. And then we had the kittens, welcomed by men but ultimately ineffective.

 

Sheryl Sandberg is a good example of the impersonator category (though also quite phenomenal), and she wrote the famous instruction manual for other ambitious women, Lean In, with the basic advice for women to suppress femininity. I always thought this was disastrous advice for most women. Why try to succeed by developing the one attribute where you are likely to be inferior to male counterparts, masculinity?

 

Women suffered many impediments on their journey to being respected and promoted as leaders. Their education used to be worse, their parents steered them into limiting professions, panels full of men selected against the criterion of people like them, i.e. more men, and women in relationships are often still the ones expected to sacrifice career, especially when they become parents.  

 

Those are the fundamental reasons why women have taken a long time to rise to the top, despite belatedly effective diversity policies in companies. Perhaps we are now past this misleading edge concept, in which the first women to break through were phenomena, impersonators or kittens.

 

My suggestion is that it is important not to take the wrong lessons from the misleading edge. I think Sandberg’s book did damage. I think the kittens did more damage, by making men feel good when they should have felt guilty and by perpetuating myths about female unsuitability when they were over promoted. The phenomena are wonderful (unless called Thatcher), but can hardly be replicated.

 

Instead, companies need to push diversity as long as it takes for real breakthroughs, even if the early results disappoint. And women should follow my favourite general advice, to be themselves. I believe women will ultimately be superior leaders, just as the current crop of female political leaders are showing. It will just take perseverance. If my career started today, I expect that my female bosses would be more numerous, and among the best rather than the worst. The leading edge are necessary, but they are not sufficient, nor indicative, nor necessarily good examples to follow.

 

This week Bagehot in The Economist gave praise to Britain’s Tory party for its diversity success. They have given us two prime ministers and now the most diverse cabinet in history. However, I do wonder if we are still witnessing a misleading edge. The ethnic minority success stories, while impressive, feel a little bit kittenish to me. I hope I am wrong.

 

If I am right about the idea of a misleading edge, it would apply equally to other facets of diversity, for example racial and sexual diversity. I could argue that the first out gay men to emerge in public were kittens like Larry Grayson. These trailblazers are good, so long as we don’t declare success too early, or try to clone them too closely, or assume that those that follow them will have the same attributes.

 

Inequities are still legion, but there is also much to celebrate in terms of diversity in societies in the developed world. But let us be careful not to fall into traps posed by the misleading edge.     

Monday, January 25, 2021

Other Covid Legacies

 I seem to be surrounded by Covid pessimism at the moment. We just returned to the US from Portugal, where cases are currently among the highest per capita in the world and where the authorities are gradually imposing more and more restrictions in an attempt to keep hospitals from overflowing.

 

Both in Portugal and in the US, this seems to be a time for a drumbeat of tough Covid messaging. The new US administration wants to demonstrate its seriousness. As the first vaccines are rolled out, both countries want to avoid any premature declaration of victory that might make people lose their discipline.

 

Business owners in affected segments have been holding on in the hope of brighter days ahead, and now wonder again if they can survive long enough to see them. Meanwhile, the perpetual Trump clickbait seems to have been replaced in the short term by lots of marginally fake news about vaccines. The web is full of discussion about which vaccine is better, horror stories about the fates of some early recipients and doom and gloom about authorities messing up their roll out plans.

 

I find all this overblown. Surely, unless we are scientists we should just accept that they are all good enough for us if a reputable body is prepared to inject it into our bloodstreams? Programmes like this are bound to have teething troubles as they ramp up a smooth operation. And scare stories about vaccine safety based on one or two cases are just irresponsible.

 

In the rich world, I believe all this fuss will be behind us quite quickly, and as soon as April it should be quite easy to get vaccinated. The Johnson and Johnson vaccine is close to approval, and having four, or even more, Western vaccines in production should remove the supply bottlenecks quickly, just as logistics ones have been solved.

 

Yes, there are still tough months ahead and we should maintain discipline. Yes, for some businesses this will mean the end. Yes, there will be plenty more setbacks. But overall we can be more optimistic, because the vaccines are coming, and I believe coming quickly.

 

By April, in rich countries we will have transitioned into a new phase. Most vulnerable people will have been vaccinated. Excess deaths will start trending downwards quickly. Businesses will be clamouring for restrictions to be lifted. Airlines and other pressure groups and governments dependent on tourism will join the chorus. And those of us who will have been vaccinated will not want to listen anymore, fatigued of deprivation and ready to party.

 

Yes, I’ll happily wear a mask in crowded places. Yes, I’ll avoid venues with poor ventilation. Yes, I’ll avoid crowded homes. But, with common sense, I will want to party, and so will most others.

 

So the question becomes how authorities react to this new phase. There is plenty of pent-up demand from the public, supported by demand from businesses. The health risk will still exist but be much lower. Should they introduce new constraints, or vaccine passports, or just allow people to use their own judgement?

 

I feel vaccine passports would be difficult in practice, except perhaps in situations like international flights. It is hardly fair to issue passports to some while others don’t yet have access to a vaccine. And do antibodies in those who have recovered count the same as a vaccine, given that the level of protection seems to be similar. And for how long should these passports be valid?

 

In practice I think most of the rich world will quickly evolve into a Swedish type model, with plenty of communication about risks, plenty of encouragement to be vaccinated, activities with very large crowds discouraged, but otherwise reliance on our own common sense. I think we will reach that stage around May 1, much sooner than the general mood currently indicates.

 

I am also optimistic about many of the lingering legacies of the pandemic. The costs have been huge, most notably for those with family members who have died, but there are reasons to believe some lessons will be learned.

 

For me the main lesson will be about how we treat our personal health. I am lucky that I am rarely sick, but I think I will be sick even less often in the future. That is because I understand so much more now about personal hygiene and health risks.

 

My habit of hand washing will become less obsessive after the pandemic, but I will wash more hands more often and more carefully than I did before 2019. I’ll be especially vigilant when entering crowded spaces like the subway or a theatre or airport terminal, probably choosing to wear a mask and certainly sanitising my hands more and avoiding touching nose and mouth. If I am sick I will try harder not to infect others and I’ll be wary of others who appear sick.

 

It makes sense that flu statistics are way down this winter, and I suspect they will be way down next year and in following years too, and the same will be true of other diseases that personal hygiene can impact.

 

There will be other positive legacies from this time. Education will be a stronger mix of online, remote and in-person tuition. Healthcare will benefit in the same way. Administrative work will find a happy balance between co-location in offices and working remotely at home. The balance will vary according to the need of the business and the preference of the individual, and all parties will benefit, even those of us trying to use roads or subways at busy times.

 

I am less optimistic about more fundamental changes, because memories can be short. We all cheered health workers by banging pans on our balconies last spring, but that is not likely to translate into better pay for those same workers once things have returned to normal. We can wish for less inequality and be made aware of people reliant on food banks, but such concerns will probably be overtaken by selfish priorities quite quickly.

 

In the same way, we can promise never again to lose touch with loved ones, and to remember to count the blessings of movement and culture and family, even to think of our neighbours, but such promises will probably be soon forgotten once life returns to normal. Heck, it won’t be long before people will be happy to vote for populist incompetents again.

 

Some changes will be subject to waves. The pandemic has opened our eyes to the stresses of a city life and the benefits of lower rents and easier commutes farther away from population centres. That will rebalance rents for a time, but then there will be a wave in the opposite direction, when youngsters will crave the excitement of city life once again. Don’t take predictions of the end of cities or theatre or tourism too seriously, people and markets will find ways to make a comeback before too long.

 

But before any of these good or bad things can happen, we have to get through this winter and wait for the vaccination programmes to gather momentum. For people in developing or poor or badly run countries, the wait might be longer. But I am optimistic for May, or even April, to see the start of the rebound in rich countries. And then the parties will be legendary – in a cautious way of course.

Monday, January 18, 2021

The Mob, C'est Moi

 The Economist included a neat short essay this week about mobs. It included some ancient history, starting with the ancient Greeks and moving through the French and American revolutions. One basic message was that it is too easy for us to become complacent about mobs and the dangers they pose.

 

We should always start and end at a personal level. When we watch the ugly scenes at the US Capitol, our first tendency is to label the perpetrators as people not like us. Surely I could never do anything so reprehensible?

 

Indeed, I can’t see myself in a MAGA hat or supporting QAnon. I could not join that mob. But it is sobering to realise that there are other mobs I could easily join. The Trump crowd like to conflate their insurrection with the BLM protests during 2019. Their argument in terms of the cause is threadbare, but in terms of the mob behaviour, they have a point. Protests in Portland and elsewhere did turn violent and threatening. There were several Sunday mornings we drove through Manhattan to observe the after-effects of destructive riots.

 

Ah, we say, complacently, that misses the point. Even if we proclaim that violence is not acceptable, even when history shows that violence against blacks has been ever-present and that only violence has led to change, we should recognise that the violence was only committed by a tiny minority in what were otherwise peaceful protests, that the police and infiltrators were probably inciting it, and that tiny minority could never include me.

 

Well, I confess, actually it could. I did not join any BLM protest in 2019 (I wish I had), but if I had, I might have joined in the violence. I reach this conclusion based on experiences from my past.

 

The nearest parallel for me was regularly attending live soccer matches at West Ham, a poor suburb on East London, during the 1980’s. I always chose to join the crowd standing in the cheap part of the ground behind the goal, not to save money and certainly not for the view (I always prayed the action was at my end, because I sure could not see much at the other end), but for the atmosphere. We chanted, we swayed, and we reached peaks of ecstasy and anger. We belonged to the tribe.

 

As an experience, it was wonderful. But looking back on it, I very easily became part of a mob, and could easily have been swept into reprehensible mob behaviour. Hurling racist and hurtful chants at opposition players and referees was bad enough, but often after the game the crowd on Green Street would swell and become threatening, and I could easily have joined in. It does not take a lot to become part of a mob – a situation, some adrenaline, and a desire to belong to a tribe.

 

A sports crowd is the nearest parallel, but others come close. I could too easily become a bully at school, and perhaps in adulthood too at work. That is not crowd violence, but it has many similarities. When we sit on our intellectual high horses, we should all remember our most tribal moments.

 

Going back to the more comfortable arena of The Economist, risk of mob rule has long been seen as the dark side of democracy. Democracy offers some power to the people, indeed it demands that the people to an active role. What if the people do not do a good job? What if our majoritarian, angry, mob tendencies come to the fore?

 

Our attitude to this dilemma often comes down to whether we have an optimistic or pessimistic tendency. Optimists tend to believe that our better natures, combined with improving education and knowledge and fair institutions, will avoid bad outcomes most of the time, and enable the fastest rate of progress. Pessimists argue for more controls, either because they fear the risks of mob rule, or they don’t trust themselves or (more often) others to get things right, preferring instead to rely on elites (often people like them).

 

I have always been an optimist in this question. For me, progress is the most important thing, so maximising creative potential and education is more important than avoiding risking control. I see the balance as a race, with education and technology and communication constantly raising the bar, usually fast enough to smother the downside risks. Even the rapid rise of China has not changed my fundamental philosophy, impressive though that rise has been and seems set to continue.

 

But those risks are present, and perhaps now are growing too quickly for education to outpace them. Communication allows for diversity and learning, but also for fear and tribalism, gives a ready voice to populists and plenty of ammunition and airtime to conspiracy theorists and resentments. And three quarters of a century without war might have led us into entitlement and complacency. We should cheer that many of the old control valves have been displaced – religion, class and national propaganda don’t work as reliably as they once did. But it does create more potential virality for mobs. We have to learn how to dampen these risks, especially the new media landscape.

 

However, The Economist makes another excellent point. Social media and rapid communication can form a breeding ground for mobs, but a well-run democracy can usually stop the mob at source by generating a positive narrative of its own, based on fair, incremental progress. And this narrative has become weaker since around 1980.

 

We can argue that Reagan and Thatcher started a process that led to the capture of US and UK democracies by a rent-seeking elite, one that has only becoming greedier over time. When one faction loses all pretence of seeking incremental fair progress, it is no wonder that the institutions start to break down and eventually that this faction itself can be captured by fanatics.

 

If this analysis is even partly correct, the dominant priority of democrats everywhere has to be to restore its commitment to fair, incremental progress. That would involve renewed focus on education, a more progressive stance on taxation, and a leg up for those people and places left behind. There is scope to debate the balance between a more socialist stance and a traditional conservative one emphasising reward for endeavour. But when much of the debate is swallowed by bigotry and resentment as a masquerade behind greed and rent seeking, we cannot be surprised if the result is an unleashed mob.

 

The Economist concludes its essay with an uncharacteristically blunt statement that democratic naivety died on January 6thin Washington. It calls for a more sophisticated democracy, defending institutions and respecting the imperative to deliver fair progress. I found this a compelling message. I am as susceptible to joining a mob as anybody else. We need to collectively remember how to nurture our better instincts, and quickly.

Friday, January 8, 2021

At last a possible Epiphany

 The momentous events in Washington on Wednesday had a chilling effect on me, even safely distanced in Portugal. We can be shocked. We can be saddened. But I find it hard to understand how anybody could be surprised. A poison has been at work in the body of USA politics, in plain view. And, like many poisons, the only way to eliminate its power is to wait until it strikes and be ready with an antidote.

 

As so often, Nancy Pelosi said it best with her reference to the day as a possible epiphany. She cleverly drops references to her Catholic faith into her speech, not in a proselytising or grandstanding way like Pence or Pompeo, but gently signalling her belief. January 6this the Christian feast of the Three Kings or Epiphany, and that word has come into everyday language to mean a moment when you suddenly feel that you understand, or suddenly becomeconscious of, something that is very important to you. If things turn out well, we could well look back on the riot of Washington in precisely those terms.

 

I applaud the Democrats for having been so patient. Attack a poison like this too early and too aggressively and it only becomes stronger. Pelosi did not want to impeach Trump and only did it when his actions became too egregious to overlook. Throughout the 2020 drumbeat of undermining trust in a fair election, and the subsequent “stop the steal” movement, I have often become frustrated at the lack of any fighting back. But they understood, and remained disciplined. Deny the conspiracy, seek to punish its perpetrators, and it only grows, and creates martyrs in its wake.

 

Instead, the affected parties have to see the poison for what it is themselves for it to lose its potency, and that is why Wednesday was a potential epiphany. Congratulations, Joe and Chuck and Nancy, you showed far more patience than I would have been able to muster, and you deserve your reward.

 

But will this prove a true epiphany, and will the reward be forthcoming? That depends on the actions of various parties over the coming months.

 

Perhaps of even more lasting significance than the insurrection this week were the senate elections in Georgia, which offer the Biden team a short window to legislate. At the least, that will stop McConnell blocking the most obvious beneficial steps. We can expect the holding hostage of states and cities to stop, so perhaps there can be an effective New York subway system after the pandemic. Probably the most lasting impact will be the climate change agenda, so John Kerry might have a true, satisfying job to do now.

 

Biden is smart enough not to try too much else. Stephen Breyer can safely retire from the Supreme Court, but trying to pack it would surely backfire. Perhaps there will be space and time to build back Obamacare with some improvements over the original. The old chestnut of infrastructure can be enacted, with obvious links to the climate change plan. We can expect a strengthening of DACA, but still no comprehensive immigration reform, and little gun control or police reform either. Biden will not want to create hostages to his fortunes in the 2022 midterms.

 

So Biden’s actions are relatively predictable, and so are Trump’s. He is still playing a long game, with an eye to re-election in 2024. After the setback of this week, he will use his notoriety to build back his cult, and surely will be as effective as ever in generating publicity. Some will be lost to him after the epiphany, but many will return, so long as the conspiracy theories are still out there and the Democrats effectively targeted as hate figures. We should not expect the events of this week to kill the poison, only to delay and weaken it.

 

My guess is that the Democrats will use the moment created by this week to maintain an attack, but then to revert to caution. There will be lawsuits, but there will still be Trump, his health permitting.

 

I believe we need to look closely at the actions of two other groups, for both of whom this week may be a turning point.

 

The first of these is Rupert Murdoch. How will the uncomfortable marriage between Donald Trump and Fox News evolve? It was already strained before the election. Fox is facing a changed media environment, Murdoch is trying to protect his legacy and hand over to his family, and Murdoch will not let his own brand become too wedded to Trump’s. Trump himself will try to cash in on his brand value, perhaps with his own TV channel.

 

Trump’s brand would look very different without Fox News. He has alternative outlets, but further from the mainstream. With Fox, he can aim for fifty million moderately obsessed fans, without it maybe ten million more extreme ones. The first scenario feels like material for a new presidential run, the second more like a dangerous outsider group. In the end it will be Rupert Murdoch’s decision.

 

The second group are mainstream Republicans, epitomised by Mitch McConnell. We can characterise McConnell as spineless over the last four years, but in reality his options have been limited. It is credible to take the opposite view and assess his performance as deft – after all, there has been no nuclear war and the constitution has largely held up, while the business elite that is his true constituency has prospered under Trump.

 

But this was always a fraught path, and McConnell knows this as well as anybody. His own performance on Wednesday, rather statesmanlike, is interesting. With two or four years to rebuild and Trump’s brand wounded, he may want to rebuild his party around another direction.

 

McConnell knows also that he is playing a dangerous game trying to mount a coup. As has been the case for the last four years, anybody attempting a coup is dead meat unless the coup succeeds, and the odds of success have so far been small. No we face a moment of opportunity. Will he grasp it?

 

I don’t think so. McConnell is inherently cautious. His own following among politicians is wafer-thin and among the public even less so. The new congressional caucus will be more pro-Trump than the outgoing one. And what alternative platform does he have? Traditional Republicanism is pretty well bankrupt.

 

On balance, I am sticking to my prediction from November. Trump will learn from Wednesday and promote a less extreme path for a time. The Democrats will return to caution. Trump may start is own media outlet, but he will realise he still needs Murdoch and Fox will largely stay in his stable. McConnell will observe this and there will be no party coup. The events of this week will recede into the background. The poison will emerge more strongly than ever, and will have a credible chance of regaining power in 2024, reverting to bleating about immigrants, China and Biden’s perceived weakness.

 

I’m sorry that this is not an optimistic projection to start a new year, or even to duly recognise the feast of Epiphany. I hope I am proved wrong.

Wednesday, December 16, 2020

Fighting Yesterday's Battles

 It would be an interesting experiment to dig out newspapers from five or ten years ago and look at the headlines. Apart from the trivial and the ever-present, my guess is that there would be much discussion about some issues that seemed highly consequential at the time but humdrum now. It is not easy to put present anxieties into a wider context.

 

As examples, think of all the military escapades of the USA since 1945. The Korean war started seventy years ago this week and the cause seemed strong enough at the time to justify deploying thousands of soldiers into a highly hostile environment and to accept that many would perish. The Bay of Pigs still holds some intensity, but Vietnam and Iraq less.

 

It is the same about more mundane domestic issues. How can we forget the discussions about toilets and changing rooms for people of rare genders? In that case, much of the excitement was generated for political ends. A cynic might claim that the same could be true of all the warmongering.

 

One of the most heartening articles I read this year was in The Economist about abortion. I find abortion to be a tough subject. I attend Catholic Mass in the USA and observe the passion that it generates. Even in 2020, our local priest came close to suggesting a vote for Trump, with abortion the deciding factor. W were asked to look beyond crime, misogyny, racism, arrogance, bullying and the rest, an antithesis of the gospel teachings, all in the cause of reducing abortion.

 

For the most passionate, the key argument is that all life is sacred. What I find hard to reconcile is that it is often these same people who accept people starving in the streets for a want of societal support, or capital punishment, or even extra-judicial killing of foreign scientists. Can we really judge those lives to be expendable whereas a creature with an undeveloped brain is not?

 

On the other hand, it should never be a trivial thing to abort a child, beyond some point where a scientist might classify it as a human being, so I have some sympathy for the anti-abortion cause.

 

The article in question did not explore these well-worn avenues, but instead pointed out how the science of having an abortion has changed. What used to be a risky operation can now be reliably undertaken at home via cheap and readily available medication, which is becoming available to more and more people in different parts of the world.

 

Over time the result will be that the harrumphing of the anti-abortion evangelicals will have less and less effect. They can close all the clinics and squeeze the professionals, but that will be of little avail if a simple prescription from the Internet will do the trick. Banning the pills would even be difficult if they are available in other countries.

 

We can hope that the upshot of all this will be a reduction in political heat. The new pills is only safe in the first trimester, but hopefully their easy availability will mean women can make a decision and act on it quickly enough. The abortion pill is little more than an extension of the morning after pill. People can still debate the point at which abortion becomes unethical, but once the discussion becomes theoretical rather than consequential it should become less intense. Continuous improvement in sex education, availability of contraceptives and male responsibilities should extend the trend of women’s agency.

 

This is a surprisingly common phenomenon: an issue enflames passions but then quickly becomes old news thanks to societal trends and some game-changing innovation. In the developed world, matters relating to LGBT people have gone this way over one generation. Prejudice still exists and other parts of the world have some catching up to do, but nowadays the diehards emit a sense of having missed the bus.

 

The challenge for activists and policy makers is to discern which issues will vanish of their own accord, which ones need only a nudge and which ones need an almighty heave. An example from a less ethically sensitive area is competition law. Twenty years ago legislators became concerned about the monopolistic behaviour of Microsoft, but the problem vanished before they could do much about it. Now the same dilemma exists concerning other tech giants. Most likely that will solve itself over time as well.

 

More difficult is the whole area of populism being fed by conspiracy theories and anger and misinformation, all turbocharged by social media. It is tempting to take an evangelical approach and seek to banish the scourge via prohibitions. But it is very hard to know what to do, partly because any restrictive action risks firing up resentments even more and creating martyrs. As an optimist, I like to hope that this issue will reduce over time too. Successive generations are better educated and less digitally naïve, and platforms will develop to drive more discerning segmentation of content. It could still be a bumpy ride for a while, especially if elites continue to ignore the challenges of inequality and deprivation.

 

Climate change is clearly an issue demanding the almighty heave. But I suspect we are reaching a tipping point, a good one in which humanity does what it needs to rather than a bad one where nature wreaks havoc. Now that the moneymen have started seriously downgrading dirty investments and worrying about insurance, momentum for necessary change will snowball. This example is also salutary, because the temptation ten years ago was to mandate all sorts of solutions, most of which would have been the wrong ones. Even an almighty heave should not be too specific.

 

The same is true for all the challenges of racism. Again, this warrants an almighty heave, but success will come more from changing minds than implementing draconian policies, though some police reform is surely in order. Rioting and tearing down statues and demanding reparations all help to make activists feel empowered, but may often be counter-productive.

 

The Economist has also been mounting a subtle campaign in the area of transsexual rights and policies. Rightly feeling guilty about past persecution of gay people, the magazine fears that society has overreacted and used an almighty heave where a nudge might be more effective. It is such an immature area, and young kids risk taking drastic changes to their bodies that they later regret. Over time things will become clearer as evidence builds up, science innovates and professionals improve their skills. If we are cautious, then some kids will surely suffer from being unjustly forced to live with the body they were born with. But is that a bigger risk than creating a cohort of kids regretting drastic changes that cannot be easily reversed?

 

I know little of the subject, but I lean towards the side of The Economist. Patience and caution should not be mistaken for conservative obstructionism. And, as the other examples show, the passage of time can have wonderful benefits. At work, prevarication and inaction can be a good strategy, when the result is a problem disappearing of its own accord. Such miracles can occur in public policy too. 

Tuesday, December 8, 2020

The Perils of Execution

 I have always been pretty hot at strategy. I can read a big picture, have good imagination for idea generation, can weigh up pros and cons and even produce some sort of plan. Where I failed it was usually in execution, and in most cases that was due to its human aspects.

 

You can’t achieve all that much alone. Your power comes from finding ways to multiply your own abilities by utilizing others. And that is a secret I never really mastered. I recall one humbling example, at a workshop given by some guru or other. There were six of us divided into two groups of three, the three bosses and the three workers. I was the senior worker at the time and was appointed their leader.

 

The whole point of the exercise was that we were supposed to win. My two team members were a Japanese guy who did everything for the group, never lacking energy or willingness, and the secretary, immersed with practical and human skills. The three bosses all talked a good game and were engineers so had some practical skills, but they were supposed to over-theorise and argue about roles while our team got on with the task at hand. Except we didn’t, and I think the reason was my terrible execution leadership. We had the smarter idea, better plan and the more diligent workers, but somehow we lost. I think the fundamental cause was that I did not care enough, and that communicated itself to my teammates.

 

I learned a lot about execution during my short spell in Major Project Management for Shell, but actually not as much as I should have, because I suspect many of the group had the same weaknesses as me. They were wonderful at process, so they made beautiful plans. Major parts of those plans involved stakeholder management and communication. But somehow things often went wrong. Just like in that workshop, this might have had something to do with passion.

 

I recall a couple of other Shell stories with lessons about execution. At one point I was somehow put in charge of building new networks of petrol stations in newly open Eastern Europe. It was a wonderful job and I think I did it quite well. We built strong models, good practices, and attracted excellent talent. We made some good decisions and left a lasting legacy. But the real success went to my successor, a Hungarian man of monumental energy and passion. He took our framework and brought it alive. It helped him that he was local and could relate to his team more authentically. He did a brilliant job.

 

Another example was in Scandinavia, where we had a failing business and I developed a strategy to turn it around. By happenstance, at a perfect moment for us Shell fell in love with a consultant who was peddling a particular method. As it turns out, the method was not especially good strategically and in most countries it failed dismally. But a team of us was able to hitch my strategy to the method and the results were spectacular. The method was the perfect vehicle for a passionate execution.

 

My last example goes against the theme, because it was a success and I was in charge. We had to integrate an acquired company into a running business before closing down the former operation. There was little guidance available, and I did a good job, I think, at defining the issue and forming a plan. Somehow my team also managed to execute it well, despite me being in charge. Perhaps by that stage I had learned a few tricks. Perhaps my team was exceptional. Perhaps the passion for the task somehow created itself. I don’t really know, but the results were certainly satisfying.

 

This discourse on execution is prompted by a series of experiences in 2020. Major Project Management has had a unique role this year because of the pandemic. Most governments have failed dismally. I think I know some reasons why.

 

First, here are some examples. In April, congress showed a rare burst of brilliance and passed a bill allocating $1200 to all citizens. The challenge was always going to be executing this and, true to form, rich people with bank accounts got their money easily whereas the people who really needed it did not. I assumed we would not qualify, but, in September, we received a general letter that led me to believe that our son actually did, so we filled out the forms and made an application. We were told that the application was valid, but three months later he still has not received the money. The funny part was what happened when he called the helpline to ask when he might receive his cash. The clerk, perhaps with a straight face, explained that it might take months because everything was moving slowly – because of the pandemic! Of course the pandemic was the solitary reason for the programme in the first place.

 

We had a similar experience this month when trying to obtain covid PCR tests.  We will be flying tomorrow and our airline demanded a PCR test carried out within 72 hours of the flight, which in practice meant yesterday. Our challenge was that most commercial providers, except the most exorbitant ones, have a turnaround time for getting results of up to week. I really wonder what the value of such a test is to anybody, since within a week we can infect most of our neighbourhood. Still, in their wisdom NYC had a particular scheme that was perfect for us, offering rapid turnaround lab tests at specific locations. The appointment could only be made two days before the test, and that led to the challenge, because the website was such that most of the time no appointments were on offer. Luckily by getting up at 4am on the relevant day I managed to game the system.

 

Since arriving in the US, we have been willing to donate blood. But at first we were told that our foreign blood wouldn’t be on any use to them, first for five years and then for seven or ten. Seemingly they believe most European blood in contaminated by mad cow disease, which would be a scary thought if I trusted the US professionals who reached that conclusion. Now, almost every week, the NYC blood service issues a call for more people to donate because the pandemic has increased demand. So I tried again, calling the helpline a couple of times, but they either failed to call back or lacked key information, so we have still been stymied.

 

All of these are execution failings. I could add many more. The NYC plan to reopen schools has lurched from problem to problem, though on that one I have sympathy for the mayor, who took a brave position and is constrained by teacher’s unions with dubious motives. Cuomo’s late intervention to a subway tunnel repair was hardly exemplary, though the outcome seems to have been good. Every encounter with the DMV has given me plenty of evidence of poor execution.

 

I can draw a few general lessons. Firstly, execution is difficult. We can all complain about the school reopening but that is a tough, multi-dimensional challenge. It should make us appreciate those organisations that seem to pull off tough execution challenges as a core competence: Amazon and IKEA come to mind. Public sector examples are harder to find, especially military ones. The Chinese seem to have acquired this competence recently, and it may be why they are progressively eating our lunch. 

 

Second, execution and politicians don’t mix. The mayor’s office doubtless had great intentions with his rapid covid testing idea, but the Major Project execution was probably a terrible process with mixed motives, little attention to motivation, and too many last-minute interventions. Politicians love to overpromise, and also hate to compromise until the very last minute, which is poison to project execution. Just ask the poor mandarins currently trying to find a Brexit path forward.

 

Lastly, passion can overcome a multitude of sins. 2020 has seen many miracles of execution along with the failings, and the key ingredient has been humans with passion. I can only admire such people, recalling that humiliating workshop when I let down my fellow workers and lost to the bosses.